Well done to Promit Ghosal (pictured below), at Columbia University, who sent a careful answer to this problem.
Promit Ghosal
The problem asked was the following. Take an integrable function on the unit interval, and for in the interval , define to be the average of over .
Then, converges pointwise to for almost all , and also converges to almost uniformly.
First, the specific partition does not have much to do with the pointwise convergence; neither does the unit interval. We can conclude from real analysis that for any which is merely locally integrable, for almost all , as . A point satisfying this property is what analysts call a Lebesgue point of . Almost all points are Lebesgue points for a locally integrable function. The result generalizes to higher dimensions, and to well shaped shrinking neighborhoods.
Now, how does one prove this probabilistically? Consider the family of sets , and consider , the sigma-algebra generated by . Fix an . Then in the probability space , where is Lebesgue measure on , the sequence is a martingale for the filtration . This is a straight verification. It therefore follows from Doob’s martingale convergence theorem that . Moreover, the convergence is almost uniform by Egoroff’s theorem.
Comments on “Student Puzzle 15: solution”