Bulletin Editor Anirban DasGupta writes:

The problem asked was to settle the possibility of consistent estimation with incomplete data in three examples, and to provide a concrete one when consistent estimation is possible.

Intuitively, in case (a), you can only infer about |μ|, but not the sign of μ. Denote Yi=|Xi|; the distribution of each Yi and hence the joint distribution of (Y1,,Yn) depends only on |μ|. Suppose c(Y1,,Yn) is a consistent estimate (tor) of μ. Fix μ>0. Then, Pμ(c(Y1,,Yn)<μ/2)=Pμ(c(Y1,,Yn)<μ/2)1, as n, which would contradict c(Y1,,Yn)Pμ under every μ.

In case (b), consistent estimation of λ is possible. This is because the family of Poisson distributions is strictly MLR in X and hence, for any k, F¯k(λ)=Pλ(X>k) is strictly increasing in λ; it is also continuous. Denote Yi=IXi>k. Then, Y¯ is a consistent estimate of F¯k(λ), and by the continuous mapping theorem, F¯k1(Y¯) is a consistent estimate of λ; the estimate may be defined arbitrarily (for example, as 1), if Y¯=0 or n.

Finally in case (c), perhaps a little surprisingly, consistent estimation of the exponential mean λ is possible as well. By a direct calculation, the fractional part Y={X} has the density g(y|λ)=1λ(1e1/λ)ey/λ,0<y<1. This is a regular one parameter Exponential family and therefore the natural parameter 1λ is consistently estimable, and so, λ is also consistently estimable. For example, a concrete consistent estimate can be constructed by estimating Eλ(Y), necessarily a strictly increasing function of the natural parameter, by Y¯, and then by using the inverse function.